The adventures of rationalism
Summary
The course traces the recurring reemergence of a rational approach to design and building form trough the history of Western architecture, from the Middle Ages to the late 20th century.
Content
The terms rational and rationalism entered architectural discourse in the early 20th century, but they are rooted in architectural culture since the Enlightenment - and even before. Rational architecture consists into an approach driven by reason, that is by the knowledge of the concrete terms through which architecture is built. This approach emerged when architecture was deduced no longer from the imitation of nature understood as divine or metaphysical concept, but from the logic itself of building, understood as scientific fact. Yet, the emergence of rationalism is profoundly intertwined with rise of Capitalism and its abstracting logic connected with trade and industry. With the advent of the industrial revolution, building form underwent a process of rationalization and optimization that escaped ancient forms of building craft. Moreover, the emergence of what Henri Lefebvre called 'abstract space' - that is, space informed by the intensification of the industrial and financial organization of society - manifested itself into an increasingly abstract construction system, that often architects attempted to mask with ornaments and classicizing forms.
It is possible to argue that rational architecture was a willful sublimation of building form, intensively reified by its industrialization. The rationalist language that emerges from the architecture of Henri Labrouste, Auguste Perret, Le Corbusier, Ludwig Hilberseimer, Mies van der Rohe, Margarete Schütte-Lihotzky, can be understood as a sublimation of the industrial logic of capitalist space. Precisely for this reason, rationalism is an architecture that accepts and yet idealizes its real conditions of production. This is both the quality, and the problem of rationalist architecture. The idealizing and essentializing tendency of rational architecture is especially visible in architecture produced within totalitarian regimes, such as Fascist Italy.
At the same time, rational architecture was also understood as an architecture governed by the possibility of judging architecture according to shared criteria. Rational architecture was the architecture of scientific reasoning about large-scale social problems, the architecture of high-modernism, the welfare state and its even distribution of resources. In this context, rational architecture consisted into a partially decommodified architecture focused on its use value. The last iteration of rationalism in architecture was its reappraisal in the 1960s and 1970s by the architects affiliated with the Tendenza movement and the 'Scuola Ticinese'. In both cases, rationalism was understood as the possibility to define the architectural project as driven by legible and thus sharable criteria that would manifest into what Italian architect Giorgio Grassi defined as 'the logic construction of architecture'.
The course will aim to reconstruct a possible history of rationalist architecture from the 'Medieval machine' to the rise of the Engineer, from Henri Labrouste to Hannes Meyer, from Ludwig Hilberseimer to Aldo Rossi.
Course sessions
1st Lecture
Medieval machine
Cistercian Architecture and the rationalization of building form
2nd Lecture
Rationalism ante-litteram
The civil and military architecture of Francesco di Giorgio
3rd Lecture
The 'Rigoristi'
Francesco Milizia, Carlo Lodoli, Andrea Memmo and the foundations of Rational Architecture
4th Lecture
Construction first
The Rise of the Engineer in 18th century France
5th Lecture
Form first
The architecture of Etienne Louis Boullée, Claude Nicholas Ledoux and the teaching of Jean-Louis-Nicholas Durand at the École Polytechnique
6th Lecture
Eclectic Rationalism
The architecture of Karl Friedrich Schinkel and Henri Labrouste
7th Lecture
Rational architecture for Real
Capitalism and the advent of the Factory in England and United States
8th Lecture
Architecture or Revolution
Le Corbusier, planning and Capitalism
9th Lecture
The ambiguities of Rationalism
Modern architecture in Fascist Italy
10th Lecture
Rationalism and Social Democracy
Rational architecture in Weimar Germany
11th Lecture
God is in the Detail
The anti-formalist architecture of Ludwig Mies van der Rohe
12th Lecture
Back to Basics
Rationalism in the architecture of Aldo Rossi and Giorgio Grassi and the Scuola Ticinese
Assistants: Marson Korbi, Theodora Giovanazzi, Constantinos Marcou, Jolanda Devalle
Learning Outcomes
By the end of the course, the student must be able to:
- Interpret in a critical manner the concepts developed during the course
- Argue the relations between rationalism, architecture and class relationships
- Develop a reflection on the relationship between historical conditions and rationalist architecture
Expected student activities
Personal work during the semester, reading of texts, personal study of a theme to be concretized into a paper of approximately 3.000 words.
Assessment methods
The main goal of the course is to encourage students to read as much as they can. Therefore, the main factor in the evaluation will be the student's capacity to assemble and read a relevant body of texts.
40% Specificity of the theme and reading relevant bibliography
40% Writing of the paper, especially referencing and footnoting
20% Clear oral exposition
Supervision
Assistants | Yes |
Others |
Dans les plans d'études
- Semestre: Printemps
- Forme de l'examen: Oral (session d'été)
- Matière examinée: The adventures of rationalism
- Cours: 2 Heure(s) hebdo x 12 semaines
- Semestre: Printemps
- Forme de l'examen: Oral (session d'été)
- Matière examinée: The adventures of rationalism
- Cours: 2 Heure(s) hebdo x 12 semaines
Semaine de référence
Lu | Ma | Me | Je | Ve | |
8-9 | |||||
9-10 | |||||
10-11 | |||||
11-12 | |||||
12-13 | |||||
13-14 | |||||
14-15 | |||||
15-16 | |||||
16-17 | |||||
17-18 | |||||
18-19 | |||||
19-20 | |||||
20-21 | |||||
21-22 |
Légendes:
Cours
Exercice, TP
Projet, autre